Maths WorkshopMaths problems with full solutions
Exercise 1671Algebra › Equations and radicalsL1Added 3 Nov 2026

A radical equation with parameter

#parameter#radical equation#conditions

Statement

For which real aa does the equation x+a=x\sqrt{x+a}=x have a real solution?

Hint

Square and check when the quadratic has a solution x≥0x\ge0 with x2≥ax^2\ge a.

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

Condition. x+a=x\sqrt{x+a}=x requires x≥0x\ge0 and x+a≥0x+a\ge0. Squaring: x+a=x2x+a=x^2, i.e. x2−x−a=0x^2-x-a=0.

Roots. x=1±1+4a2x=\frac{1\pm\sqrt{1+4a}}{2}, requiring a≥−1/4a\ge-1/4.

Condition x≥0x\ge0. With a≥−1/4a\ge-1/4, the root x+=1+1+4a2>0x_+=\frac{1+\sqrt{1+4a}}{2}>0. So x+x_+ is valid provided x+2−x+−a=0x_+^2-x_+-a=0 and x++a≥0x_++a\ge0. From x2=x+ax^2=x+a, x+a=x2≥0x+a=x^2\ge0 automatically. So x+x_+ works.

The root x−=1−1+4a2x_-=\frac{1-\sqrt{1+4a}}{2} is ≥0\ge0 iff 1+4a≤1\sqrt{1+4a}\le1, i.e. a≤0a\le0. And a≥−1/4a\ge-1/4.

Conclusion. For a≥−1/4a\ge-1/4, the equation has at least one solution (namely x+x_+). For a∈[−1/4,0]a\in[-1/4,0], it has two solutions (x+x_+ and x−x_-).