Maths WorkshopMaths problems with full solutions
Exercise 777Calculus › Single-variable calculus › SequencesL1Added 2 Nov 2026

Supremum, infimum, limsup and liminf

#supremum#limsup#liminf#bounded sequences

Statement

For each sequence (n≥1n\ge1), find sup⁡\sup, inf⁡\inf, lim sup⁡\limsup, lim inf⁡\liminf, and say whether the sup and inf are attained.

  1. un=(−1)nnn+1u_n=(-1)^n\dfrac n{n+1}
  2. vn=(−1)n+1nv_n=(-1)^n+\dfrac1n
Hint

Treat even and odd indices separately: they form two monotone subsequences.

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

1. For even nn: un=nn+1u_n=\frac n{n+1} increases to 11 without reaching it. For odd nn: un=−nn+1u_n=-\frac n{n+1} decreases to −1-1 without reaching it. Hence
sup⁡un=1, inf⁡un=−1 (not attained),lim sup⁡un=1, lim inf⁡un=−1.\sup u_n=1,\ \inf u_n=-1\ \text{(not attained)},\qquad\limsup u_n=1,\ \liminf u_n=-1.

2. For even nn: vn=1+1nv_n=1+\frac1n decreases to 11, with maximum v2=32v_2=\frac32. For odd nn: vn=−1+1nv_n=-1+\frac1n is 00 at n=1n=1 and then decreases to −1-1 without reaching it. Hence
sup⁡vn=32 (attained),inf⁡vn=−1 (not attained),lim sup⁡vn=1, lim inf⁡vn=−1.\sup v_n=\frac32\ \text{(attained)},\quad\inf v_n=-1\ \text{(not attained)},\qquad\limsup v_n=1,\ \liminf v_n=-1.

Remark. The supremum describes the *whole* sequence, whereas lim sup⁡\limsup only describes its behaviour at the tail. In example 2 they differ (32\frac32 versus 11) because the largest value occurs early. A bounded sequence converges iff lim sup⁡=lim inf⁡\limsup=\liminf.