Maths WorkshopMaths problems with full solutions
Exercise 1456Topology › Topology of Mn(ℝ) › Applications and the case n = 2L3Added 10 Nov 2026

The cone of positive definite 2×2 matrices is a light cone

#positive definite matrices#convex cone#Sym2#boundary

Statement

Let Sym2≅R3\mathrm{Sym}_2\cong\mathbb{R}^3 be the space of symmetric matrices (abbc)\begin{pmatrix}a&b\\b&c\end{pmatrix} with coordinates (a,b,c)(a,b,c).

  1. Show that the set PD\mathrm{PD} of positive definite matrices is {(a,b,c):a>0, ac>b2}\{(a,b,c):a>0,\ ac>b^2\}.
  2. Show that PD\mathrm{PD} is an open convex cone homeomorphic to R3\mathbb{R}^3.
  3. Show that its boundary in Sym2\mathrm{Sym}_2 (the singular positive semidefinite matrices) is the circular cone {ac=b2, a,c≥0}\{ac=b^2,\ a,c\ge0\}.
Hint

Put a=x+ya=x+y, c=x−yc=x-y. Then ac−b2=x2−y2−b2ac-b^2=x^2-y^2-b^2, so positive definiteness becomes x>y2+b2x>\sqrt{y^2+b^2}.

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

Idea. The determinant of a 2×22\times2 symmetric matrix is a Lorentzian quadratic form in suitable coordinates, and PD\mathrm{PD} is the "future light cone".

Part 1: criterion. Let S=(abbc)S=\begin{pmatrix}a&b\\b&c\end{pmatrix} and u=(u1,u2)≠0u=(u_1,u_2)\ne0. If a>0a>0, completing the square,
uTSu=au12+2bu1u2+cu22=a(u1+bau2)2+(c−b2a)u22.u^TSu=au_1^2+2bu_1u_2+cu_2^2=a\Bigl(u_1+\frac bau_2\Bigr)^2+\Bigl(c-\frac{b^2}a\Bigr)u_2^2.
If ac>b2ac>b^2 then c−b2/a>0c-b^2/a>0 and the form is positive for u≠0u\ne0 (both squares vanish only if u2=0u_2=0 and then u1=0u_1=0). Conversely, if SS is positive definite then a=e1TSe1>0a=e_1^TSe_1>0 and, taking u=(−b,a)u=(-b,a), uTSu=a(ac−b2)>0u^TSu=a(ac-b^2)>0 gives ac>b2ac>b^2. (Equivalently: Sylvester's criterion.)

Part 2: cone, convexity, homeomorphism. Put x=a+c2x=\frac{a+c}2, y=a−c2y=\frac{a-c}2, so a=x+ya=x+y, c=x−yc=x-y, and (a,b,c)↦(x,y,b)(a,b,c)\mapsto(x,y,b) is a linear isomorphism. Then ac−b2=x2−y2−b2ac-b^2=x^2-y^2-b^2.
- If x>y2+b2x>\sqrt{y^2+b^2}, then x>0x>0 and x2>y2+b2x^2>y^2+b^2; then a=x+y≥x−∣y∣>0a=x+y\ge x-|y|>0 and ac−b2>0ac-b^2>0, so the matrix is PD.
- Conversely, if a>0a>0 and ac>b2≥0ac>b^2\ge0 then c>0c>0, so x=a+c2>0x=\frac{a+c}2>0, and x2>y2+b2x^2>y^2+b^2 gives x>y2+b2x>\sqrt{y^2+b^2}.

Hence PD={(x,y,b):x>∥(y,b)∥}\mathrm{PD}=\{(x,y,b):x>\|(y,b)\|\}, where ∥⋅∥\|\cdot\| is the Euclidean norm of R2\mathbb{R}^2. It is *open* (the strict inequality between continuous functions), a *cone* (stable under multiplication by λ>0\lambda>0) and *convex*: if xi>∥(yi,bi)∥x_i>\|(y_i,b_i)\| then for λ∈[0,1]\lambda\in[0,1], by the triangle inequality ∥λ(y1,b1)+(1−λ)(y2,b2)∥≤λ∥(y1,b1)∥+(1−λ)∥(y2,b2)∥<λx1+(1−λ)x2\|\lambda(y_1,b_1)+(1-\lambda)(y_2,b_2)\|\le\lambda\|(y_1,b_1)\|+(1-\lambda)\|(y_2,b_2)\|<\lambda x_1+(1-\lambda)x_2.

*Homeomorphism with R3\mathbb{R}^3.* The map (x,y,b)↦(y,b,ln⁡(x−∥(y,b)∥))(x,y,b)\mapsto\bigl(y,b,\ln(x-\|(y,b)\|)\bigr) is a continuous bijection from PD\mathrm{PD} onto R2×R\mathbb{R}^2\times\mathbb{R} with continuous inverse (y,b,s)↦(∥(y,b)∥+es,y,b)(y,b,s)\mapsto(\|(y,b)\|+e^s,y,b).

Part 3: boundary. The set F={x≥∥(y,b)∥}F=\{x\ge\|(y,b)\|\} is closed. Every point of {x=∥(y,b)∥}\{x=\|(y,b)\|\} is the limit of the points (x+1k,y,b)∈PD(x+\frac1k,y,b)\in\mathrm{PD}. Hence PD‾=F\overline{\mathrm{PD}}=F, and since PD\mathrm{PD} is open, ∂ PD=F∖PD={x=∥(y,b)∥}\partial\,\mathrm{PD}=F\setminus\mathrm{PD}=\{x=\|(y,b)\|\}. In the original coordinates, x=y2+b2x=\sqrt{y^2+b^2} means x≥0x\ge0 and x2−y2=b2x^2-y^2=b^2, i.e. ac=b2ac=b^2 and a+c≥0a+c\ge0; together with ac=b2≥0ac=b^2\ge0 this means a,c≥0a,c\ge0 (they have the same sign and a nonnegative sum). So
∂ PD={(a,b,c):ac=b2, a,c≥0},\partial\,\mathrm{PD}=\{(a,b,c):ac=b^2,\ a,c\ge0\},
the set of positive semidefinite singular matrices, a circular cone with vertex 00.

Check. S=IS=I has (x,y,b)=(1,0,0)(x,y,b)=(1,0,0) with x>0x>0. S=(1111)S=\begin{pmatrix}1&1\\1&1\end{pmatrix} has (x,y,b)=(1,0,1)(x,y,b)=(1,0,1), x=∥(y,b)∥x=\|(y,b)\|: on the boundary (it is PSD with det⁡=0\det=0).

Remark. In the Minkowski space R2,1\mathbb{R}^{2,1} with the form x2−y2−b2=det⁡Sx^2-y^2-b^2=\det S, PD\mathrm{PD} is the open future light cone. This is the picture behind the hyperbolic plane PD∩{det⁡=1}≅H2\mathrm{PD}\cap\{\det=1\}\cong\mathbb{H}^2 and its link with SL2(R)SL_2(\mathbb{R}).

Lesson. Choose coordinates in which the defining quadratic form is diagonal; cones become norm inequalities.