Maths WorkshopMaths problems with full solutions
Exercise 1452Topology › Topology of Mn(ℝ) › Applications and the case n = 2L3Added 10 Nov 2026

The singular matrices of M_2(R) form a cone over a torus

#M_2#singular matrices#rank one#torus#cone

Statement

With the coordinates (z,w)(z,w) of the previous problems, show that the set of singular matrices of M2(R)M_2(\mathbb{R}) is the cone {∣z∣=∣w∣}\{|z|=|w|\} over a torus, and that the set of rank-one matrices is homeomorphic to T2×(0,∞)T^2\times(0,\infty), where T2=S1×S1T^2=S^1\times S^1.

Hint

det⁡A=0  ⟺  ∣z∣=∣w∣\det A=0\iff|z|=|w|. If ∣z∣=∣w∣=ρ>0|z|=|w|=\rho>0, write z=ρeiαz=\rho e^{i\alpha} and w=ρeiβw=\rho e^{i\beta}.

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

Idea. The singular matrices are the null cone of the quadratic form ∣z∣2−∣w∣2|z|^2-|w|^2. A nonzero point of it has two nonzero phases (α,β)(\alpha,\beta) and a radius ρ\rho.

Step 1: description. A matrix is singular iff det⁡A=∣z∣2−∣w∣2=0\det A=|z|^2-|w|^2=0, i.e. ∣z∣=∣w∣|z|=|w|. It is zero iff z=w=0z=w=0. A matrix of rank one is singular and nonzero: ∣z∣=∣w∣=ρ>0|z|=|w|=\rho>0.

Step 2: rank-one matrices. Consider
Ψ:T2×(0,∞)→{rank one},(eiα,eiβ,ρ)↦(ρeiα,ρeiβ).\Psi:T^2\times(0,\infty)\to\{\text{rank one}\},\qquad(e^{i\alpha},e^{i\beta},\rho)\mapsto(\rho e^{i\alpha},\rho e^{i\beta}).
It is continuous, bijective, and its inverse (z,w)↦(z/∣z∣, w/∣w∣, ∣z∣)(z,w)\mapsto(z/|z|,\,w/|w|,\,|z|) is continuous on {∣z∣=∣w∣>0}\{|z|=|w|>0\}. So Ψ\Psi is a homeomorphism: the rank-one matrices are homeomorphic to T2×(0,∞)T^2\times(0,\infty).

Step 3: the whole singular set is the cone. The cone over T2T^2 is C(T2)=T2×[0,∞)/(T2×{0})C(T^2)=T^2\times[0,\infty)/(T^2\times\{0\}). The extended map Ψ‾:T2×[0,∞)→{∣z∣=∣w∣}\overline\Psi:T^2\times[0,\infty)\to\{|z|=|w|\}, (eiα,eiβ,ρ)↦(ρeiα,ρeiβ)(e^{i\alpha},e^{i\beta},\rho)\mapsto(\rho e^{i\alpha},\rho e^{i\beta}) is a continuous surjection that is proper (it satisfies ∥(z,w)∥=2ρ\|(z,w)\|=\sqrt2\rho, so preimages of bounded sets are bounded, and T2T^2 is compact), hence a closed map. It identifies exactly the points of T2×{0}T^2\times\{0\} (they all go to 00). A closed continuous surjection is a quotient map, so it induces a homeomorphism C(T2)≅{singular matrices}C(T^2)\cong\{\text{singular matrices}\}.

Check. Consistency with the algebra: every rank-one matrix is uvTuv^T with u,v∈R2∖{0}u,v\in\mathbb{R}^2\setminus\{0\}, determined up to (u,v)∼(λu,λ−1v)(u,v)\sim(\lambda u,\lambda^{-1}v). Normalising uu to a unit vector (using the freedom λ=1/∣u∣\lambda=1/|u|), the pair (u,v)(u,v) becomes a point of S1×(R2∖{0})≅S1×S1×(0,∞)S^1\times(\mathbb{R}^2\setminus\{0\})\cong S^1\times S^1\times(0,\infty), and the only remaining ambiguity is (u,v)∼(−u,−v)(u,v)\sim(-u,-v), a free involution on this space. The quotient of the torus factor by this free involution is again a torus, in agreement with Step 2. A numerical test on random uvTuv^T confirms ∣z∣=∣w∣|z|=|w|.

Remark. The singular set is *not* a manifold at 00: removing the vertex disconnects a small neighbourhood into pieces that do not look like a ball of R3\mathbb{R}^3. The rank-one set is a smooth 33-manifold, a "tube" T2×(0,∞)T^2\times(0,\infty), that is, the light cone of a quadratic form of signature (2,2)(2,2) minus its vertex.

Lesson. A homogeneous equation q(z,w)=0q(z,w)=0 defines a cone: study it through its "link" (the intersection with the unit sphere), here a torus.