Countably many proper subspaces never cover M_n
Statement
Show that cannot be written as a union of finitely many proper subspaces, nor as a union of countably many proper subspaces.
Hint
Each proper subspace is closed with empty interior. Use the Baire category theorem (a non-empty complete metric space is not a countable union of closed nowhere dense sets).
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Idea. Proper subspaces are "small" in the topological sense (closed nowhere dense); a complete space is "large" (Baire).
Step 1: proper subspaces are closed nowhere dense. By the earlier problem on subspaces, a proper subspace is closed with empty interior, i.e. nowhere dense.
Step 2: is a complete metric space. It is isometric to with the Frobenius norm.
Step 3: Baire. Suppose with each a proper subspace. This is a countable union of closed nowhere dense sets covering a non-empty complete metric space, contradicting the Baire category theorem. The finite case is a special case (repeat the subspaces).
Elementary proof for finitely many. Suppose are proper subspaces covering , with minimal. Pick not in (it exists by minimality) and . For , the points are distinct for distinct ; none lies in (else as ). Each of the infinitely many points lies in some with , so one contains two of them, and , hence and : contradiction.
Remark.
- The finite statement is a property of *infinite* fields: over the space is the union of the three lines through the origin.
- The countable statement is false in a non-complete space: is a countable union of points.
- The example from the previous problem shows that a union of *countably many hyperplanes (affine ones)* can be dense without being everything.