Proper subspaces are closed with empty interior
Statement
Show that every proper linear subspace is closed and has empty interior.
Hint
Closedness: a finite-dimensional subspace of a normed space is complete. Empty interior: if contained a ball, use small multiples of any vector to show .
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Idea. A subspace that contains even a tiny ball contains every direction, hence is everything. And finite-dimensional subspaces cannot have "holes" in their closure.
Step 1: is closed. is a finite-dimensional normed space, hence complete (it is isometric to some after choosing an orthonormal basis for the Frobenius inner product). A complete subset of a metric space is closed: if and , the sequence is Cauchy in , so it converges to some , and by uniqueness of limits .
(Another argument: is the common kernel of finitely many linear functionals , which are continuous, so is closed.)
Step 2: empty interior. Suppose contained an open ball with (a point of the interior may be taken to be the centre of a ball inside ; since the ball is inside , its centre is in ). Take any in and put
Then , so and both lie in . Since is a subspace,
As was arbitrary, , contradicting properness.
Remark.
- The same proof works in any normed space: a proper subspace has empty interior. Closedness, however, genuinely needs finite dimension (the polynomials form a dense proper subspace of ).
- This statement is used constantly: for instance the symmetric matrices, the trace-zero matrices and the commutant of a non-scalar matrix are all closed nowhere dense sets.