Maths WorkshopMaths problems with full solutions
Exercise 670Topology › Topology of Mn(ℝ) › Open, closed, interior, boundaryL2Added 7 Nov 2026

Open ball, closed ball and sphere in the operator norm

#operator norm#ball#closure#boundary

Statement

For the operator norm, show that {∥A∥<1}\{\|A\|<1\} is open, that its closure is {∥A∥≤1}\{\|A\|\le1\}, and that its boundary is {∥A∥=1}\{\|A\|=1\}.

Hint

Continuity of ∥⋅∥\|\cdot\| gives openness and closedness. For the closure, push a point of the closed ball slightly towards 00 by scaling.

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

Idea. In any normed space the open unit ball is the interior of the closed unit ball, and the closed ball is the closure of the open one. The proof is the "radial scaling" trick.

Step 1: openness and closedness. The norm is 11-Lipschitz: ∣ ∥A∥−∥B∥ ∣≤∥A−B∥|\,\|A\|-\|B\|\,|\le\|A-B\|, hence continuous. So U={∥A∥<1}=∥⋅∥−1((−∞,1))U=\{\|A\|<1\}=\|\cdot\|^{-1}((-\infty,1)) is open and F={∥A∥≤1}=∥⋅∥−1((−∞,1])F=\{\|A\|\le1\}=\|\cdot\|^{-1}((-\infty,1]) is closed.

Step 2: U‾=F\overline U=F.
- Since U⊂FU\subset F and FF is closed, U‾⊂F\overline U\subset F.
- Conversely let ∥A∥≤1\|A\|\le1. For t∈(0,1)t\in(0,1), ∥tA∥=t∥A∥<1\|tA\|=t\|A\|<1, so tA∈UtA\in U, and
∥tA−A∥=(1−t)∥A∥≤1−t⟶0(t→1−).\|tA-A\|=(1-t)\|A\|\le1-t\longrightarrow0\quad(t\to1^-).
Hence A∈U‾A\in\overline U.

Step 3: the boundary. For an open set UU the boundary is ∂U=U‾∖U\partial U=\overline U\setminus U (because UU equals its interior). Thus
∂U=F∖U={∥A∥=1}.\partial U=F\setminus U=\{\|A\|=1\}.

Remark.
- Nothing here uses that the norm is the operator norm: the argument works for *any* norm on *any* real normed space (with U≠∅U\ne\emptyset).
- In the metric space Mn(R)M_n(\mathbb{R}) one should not confuse "closed ball is closure of the open ball" with the general metric-space statement, which is false for discrete metrics. Here it holds because of the linear structure.