Maths WorkshopMaths problems with full solutions
Exercise 1947Geometry › Plane geometryL1Added 4 Nov 2026

The three external bisectors meet the sides on a line

#Menelaus's theorem#angle bisector theorem#collinearity

Statement

Let ABCABC be a triangle with three different side lengths. The external bisector of the angle at AA meets the line BCBC at DD; the external bisector at BB meets CACA at EE; the external bisector at CC meets ABAB at FF. Prove that DD, EE, FF are collinear.

Hint

Use the external angle bisector theorem: DBDC=ABAC\dfrac{DB}{DC}=\dfrac{AB}{AC}, with DD outside the segment BCBC. Then apply the converse of Menelaus's theorem.

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

Idea. Compute the three ratios with the bisector theorem and check that the product is +1+1.

Existence. The external bisector at AA is parallel to BCBC iff AB=ACAB=AC; since the sides are pairwise different, the three points exist.

The ratios. By the external bisector theorem,
DBDC=cb,ECEA=ac,FAFB=ba,\frac{DB}{DC}=\frac{c}{b},\qquad\frac{EC}{EA}=\frac{a}{c},\qquad\frac{FA}{FB}=\frac{b}{a},
where a=BC,b=CA,c=ABa=BC,b=CA,c=AB. The product is 11.

Signs. Each of D,E,FD,E,F is *outside* the corresponding segment, so each signed ratio is positive. Thus the signed product is +1+1.

Menelaus. The standard form says D,E,FD,E,F are collinear iff BD‾DC‾⋅CE‾EA‾⋅AF‾FB‾=−1\frac{\overline{BD}}{\overline{DC}}\cdot\frac{\overline{CE}}{\overline{EA}}\cdot\frac{\overline{AF}}{\overline{FB}}=-1. Since DB‾=−BD‾\overline{DB}=-\overline{BD}, etc., our product equals −- of this standard product; "our product =+1=+1" is equivalent, so D,E,FD,E,F are collinear. ■\blacksquare

Remark. For *internal* bisectors the feet are inside the sides and the lines concur (Ceva); for *external* ones the feet are collinear (Menelaus).

Lesson. Ceva = concurrency of cevians, Menelaus = collinearity of points on the side lines; both reduce to a product of ratios equal to ±1\pm1.