The three external bisectors meet the sides on a line
Statement
Let be a triangle with three different side lengths. The external bisector of the angle at meets the line at ; the external bisector at meets at ; the external bisector at meets at . Prove that , , are collinear.
Hint
Use the external angle bisector theorem: , with outside the segment . Then apply the converse of Menelaus's theorem.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Idea. Compute the three ratios with the bisector theorem and check that the product is .
Existence. The external bisector at is parallel to iff ; since the sides are pairwise different, the three points exist.
The ratios. By the external bisector theorem,
where . The product is .
Signs. Each of is *outside* the corresponding segment, so each signed ratio is positive. Thus the signed product is .
Menelaus. The standard form says are collinear iff . Since , etc., our product equals of this standard product; "our product " is equivalent, so are collinear.
Remark. For *internal* bisectors the feet are inside the sides and the lines concur (Ceva); for *external* ones the feet are collinear (Menelaus).
Lesson. Ceva = concurrency of cevians, Menelaus = collinearity of points on the side lines; both reduce to a product of ratios equal to .