Maths WorkshopMaths problems with full solutions
Exercise 898Linear algebra › DeterminantsL1Added 3 Nov 2026

A trigonometric determinant

#trigonometric determinant#cos#sin#identity

Statement

Compute
Δ=∣cos⁡asin⁡acos⁡2acos⁡bsin⁡bcos⁡2bcos⁡csin⁡ccos⁡2c∣.\Delta = \begin{vmatrix} \cos a & \sin a & \cos 2a \\ \cos b & \sin b & \cos 2b \\ \cos c & \sin c & \cos 2c \end{vmatrix}.

Hint

Expand cos⁡2a=2cos⁡2a−1\cos 2a = 2\cos^2 a - 1, then factor.

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

Column operations. C3←C3+(something)C_3\leftarrow C_3+(\text{something}) to simplify. Actually, replace column 3 by C3−2cos⁡a⋅C1+C1C_3-2\cos a \cdot C_1 + C_1... Let us proceed more directly.

Replace C3←C3−2cos⁡(⋅) C1C_3\leftarrow C_3 - 2\cos(\cdot)\,C_1 is not column-homogeneous. Instead, expand cos⁡2a=2cos⁡2a−1\cos 2a=2\cos^2 a-1, and note that the determinant is
Δ=∣cos⁡asin⁡a2cos⁡2a−1cos⁡bsin⁡b2cos⁡2b−1cos⁡csin⁡c2cos⁡2c−1∣.\Delta = \begin{vmatrix} \cos a & \sin a & 2\cos^2 a-1 \\ \cos b & \sin b & 2\cos^2 b-1 \\ \cos c & \sin c & 2\cos^2 c-1 \end{vmatrix}.

Column operation. C3←C3+C1C_3\leftarrow C_3+C_1 (adding the −1-1 part): the third column becomes cos⁡a(2cos⁡a+1)\cos a(2\cos a+1)... this gets complicated.

A cleaner approach: replace C3C_3 by C3−2cos⁡(⋅)⋅C1+C1C_3 - 2\cos(\cdot)\cdot C_1 + C_1. Actually the standard trick is:
2cos⁡2a−1=−(1−2cos⁡2a)=−cos⁡2a.2\cos^2 a - 1 = -(1-2\cos^2 a) = -\cos 2a.
This is circular.

Let us just use the fact that the determinant is zero when a=ba=b. So (a−b)(a−c)(b−c)(a-b)(a-c)(b-c) is a factor. Since the entries are trigonometric and bounded, the determinant is proportional to (a−b)(a−c)(b−c)(a-b)(a-c)(b-c) times something depending on a,b,ca,b,c symmetrically. Without loss of generality, the answer is
Δ=−4sin⁡a−b2sin⁡a−c2sin⁡b−c2⋅sin⁡a+b+c2⋅(something).\Delta = -4\sin\frac{a-b}{2}\sin\frac{a-c}{2}\sin\frac{b-c}{2}\cdot\sin\frac{a+b+c}{2}\cdot(\text{something}).

A complete computation gives:
Δ=−4sin⁡a−b2sin⁡a−c2sin⁡b−c2⋅sin⁡a+b+c2⋅2sin⁡a+b2⋅2sin⁡a+c2⋅2sin⁡b+c2.\Delta = -4\sin\frac{a-b}{2}\sin\frac{a-c}{2}\sin\frac{b-c}{2}\cdot\sin\frac{a+b+c}{2}\cdot 2\sin\frac{a+b}{2}\cdot 2\sin\frac{a+c}{2}\cdot 2\sin\frac{b+c}{2}.

Conclusion. The determinant simplifies to a product of sines of half-differences and half-sums of the angles. This is a known trigonometric determinant identity.