Exercise 718Calculus › Single-variable calculus › LimitsL1Added 1 Nov 2026
x sin x has no limit at infinity
#sequences#non-existence of limits#infinite limits
Statement
Let . Show that has no limit as , not even an infinite one.
Hint
Find a sequence with and another sequence with .
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Idea. The factor makes unbounded, which suggests . But keeps vanishing at the multiples of . Two different sequences will show the contradiction.
First sequence. Let . Then and .
Second sequence. Let . Then and for all , so .
Conclusion. If had a limit (finite or infinite) at , it would be the limit along every sequence tending to . But the two sequences give and . So has no limit at .
Remark. The function is unbounded, yet it does not tend to infinity. This is a good example showing that "unbounded" and "tends to infinity" are different properties.