Maths WorkshopMaths problems with full solutions
Exercise 127Calculus › Single-variable calculus › Differentiation › Optimisation and curve sketchingL1Added 4 Nov 2026

The strongest beam cut from a log

#optimisation#geometry#engineering#Pythagoras

Statement

A rectangular beam is cut from a circular log of diameter dd. Its strength is proportional to wh2wh^2, where ww is its width and hh its height. What dimensions give the strongest beam?

Hint

The cross-section is inscribed in the circle, so w2+h2=d2w^2+h^2=d^2. Express wh2wh^2 with ww only.

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

Strength. h2=d2−w2h^2=d^2-w^2, so S(w)=w(d2−w2)=d2w−w3S(w)=w(d^2-w^2)=d^2w-w^3 for 0<w<d0<w<d.

Maximum. S′(w)=d2−3w2=0  ⟺  w=d3S'(w)=d^2-3w^2=0\iff w=\dfrac d{\sqrt3}. Since S′>0S'>0 on (0,d3)\left(0,\frac d{\sqrt3}\right) and S′<0S'<0 on (d3,d)\left(\frac d{\sqrt3},d\right), it is the global maximum on (0,d)(0,d).

Dimensions.
w=d3≈0.577 d,h=d2−d23=d23≈0.816 d.w=\frac d{\sqrt3}\approx0.577\,d,\qquad h=\sqrt{d^2-\frac{d^2}3}=d\sqrt{\frac23}\approx0.816\,d.
Thus hw=2\dfrac hw=\sqrt2.

Remark. The strongest beam is not the one of largest area (that would be the square, w=hw=h). Tall beams resist bending better, which is why floor joists are laid on edge.