Maths WorkshopMaths problems with full solutions
Exercise 137Calculus › Single-variable calculus › Differentiation › Optimisation and curve sketchingL2Added 4 Nov 2026

Among triangles with a given base and perimeter, the isosceles one is the largest

#optimisation#Heron's formula#triangle

Statement

A triangle has a fixed base bb and the sum of its other two sides is a fixed number s>bs>b. Show that its area is maximal when the two other sides are equal, and compute this maximal area.

Hint

Call xx and s−xs-x the other two sides and use Heron's formula A2=σ(σ−a1)(σ−a2)(σ−a3)A^2=\sigma(\sigma-a_1)(\sigma-a_2)(\sigma-a_3) where σ\sigma is the semi-perimeter.

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

Heron. The semi-perimeter σ=b+s2\sigma=\frac{b+s}2 is constant. The sides are bb, xx, s−xs-x, hence
A2=σ(σ−b)⋅(σ−x)(σ−(s−x)).A^2=\sigma(\sigma-b)\cdot(\sigma-x)\bigl(\sigma-(s-x)\bigr).
Since A>0A>0, maximising AA is equivalent to maximising A2A^2.

The variable part. With u=x−s2u=x-\frac s2, we have σ−x=b2−u\sigma-x=\frac b2-u and σ−(s−x)=b2+u\sigma-(s-x)=\frac b2+u, so
(σ−x)(σ−s+x)=b24−u2.(\sigma-x)\bigl(\sigma-s+x\bigr)=\frac{b^2}4-u^2.
The triangle inequalities hold exactly when ∣u∣<b2|u|<\frac b2, and on this range the expression above is maximal at u=0u=0, i.e. x=s2x=\frac s2: the isosceles triangle.

Value. σ(σ−b)=(s+b)(s−b)4=s2−b24\sigma(\sigma-b)=\dfrac{(s+b)(s-b)}4=\dfrac{s^2-b^2}4, so
Amax⁡2=s2−b24⋅b24,Amax⁡=b4s2−b2.A_{\max}^2=\frac{s^2-b^2}4\cdot\frac{b^2}4,\qquad A_{\max}=\frac b4\sqrt{s^2-b^2}.

Remark. Geometrically: the apex moves on an ellipse with foci at the endpoints of the base (the sum of the distances ss is constant), and the highest point of this ellipse is above the middle of the base.