Maths WorkshopMaths problems with full solutions
Exercise 2244Topology › Topology of Mn(ℝ) › Rank, spectrum and normsM1Added 6 Nov 2026

The square root is operator monotone

#Loewner order#operator monotone#square root#positive semidefinite

Statement

Let A,BA,B be symmetric matrices with 0≤A≤B0\le A\le B (Loewner order: B−AB-A is positive semidefinite). Show that A≤B\sqrt A\le\sqrt B, where ⋅\sqrt{\cdot} is the positive semidefinite square root.

Hint

First treat positive definite A,BA,B. Put X=B−AX=\sqrt B-\sqrt A and check the identity B−A=B X+XAB-A=\sqrt B\,X+X\sqrt A. Evaluate vT(B−A)vv^T(B-A)v on an eigenvector vv of XX.

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

Step 1: positive definite case. Assume 0<A≤B0<A\le B and let X=B−AX=\sqrt B-\sqrt A, a symmetric matrix. We have the algebraic identity
B X+XA=B−BA+BA−A=B−A.\sqrt B\,X+X\sqrt A=B-\sqrt B\sqrt A+\sqrt B\sqrt A-A=B-A.
Suppose XX had a negative eigenvalue λ<0\lambda<0 with eigenvector v≠0v\ne0. Since XX is symmetric, vTX=λvTv^TX=\lambda v^T and Xv=λvXv=\lambda v. Then
vT(B−A)v=vTB Xv+vTXA v=λ vTB v+λ vTA v=λ(vTBv+vTAv)<0,v^T(B-A)v=v^T\sqrt B\,Xv+v^TX\sqrt A\,v=\lambda\,v^T\sqrt B\,v+\lambda\,v^T\sqrt A\,v=\lambda\big(v^T\sqrt Bv+v^T\sqrt Av\big)<0,
because A\sqrt A and B\sqrt B are positive definite so the bracket is positive, while λ<0\lambda<0. This contradicts B−A≥0B-A\ge0. So all eigenvalues of XX are ≥0\ge0, i.e. A≤B\sqrt A\le\sqrt B.

Step 2: general case. If 0≤A≤B0\le A\le B, then for each ε>0\varepsilon>0, 0<A+εI≤B+εI0<A+\varepsilon I\le B+\varepsilon I, so by Step 1
A+εI≤B+εI.\sqrt{A+\varepsilon I}\le\sqrt{B+\varepsilon I}.
The square root is continuous on the cone of positive semidefinite matrices, and the set {(X,Y):X≤Y}\{(X,Y):X\le Y\} is closed. Letting ε→0\varepsilon\to0 gives A≤B\sqrt A\le\sqrt B.

Example. The analogous statement for squares is false: A=(1111)≤B=(2111)A=\begin{pmatrix}1&1\\1&1\end{pmatrix}\le B=\begin{pmatrix}2&1\\1&1\end{pmatrix} but A2=(2222)≰B2=(5332)A^2=\begin{pmatrix}2&2\\2&2\end{pmatrix}\not\le B^2=\begin{pmatrix}5&3\\3&2\end{pmatrix}, since B2−A2=(3110)B^2-A^2=\begin{pmatrix}3&1\\1&0\end{pmatrix} has determinant −1<0-1<0.

Remark. More generally t↦trt\mapsto t^r is operator monotone for 0≤r≤10\le r\le1 (L\"owner-Heinz inequality) and not for r>1r>1. This result is one of the first examples where order on matrices behaves differently from order on numbers.