The square root is operator monotone
Statement
Let be symmetric matrices with (Loewner order: is positive semidefinite). Show that , where is the positive semidefinite square root.
Hint
First treat positive definite . Put and check the identity . Evaluate on an eigenvector of .
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Step 1: positive definite case. Assume and let , a symmetric matrix. We have the algebraic identity
Suppose had a negative eigenvalue with eigenvector . Since is symmetric, and . Then
because and are positive definite so the bracket is positive, while . This contradicts . So all eigenvalues of are , i.e. .
Step 2: general case. If , then for each , , so by Step 1
The square root is continuous on the cone of positive semidefinite matrices, and the set is closed. Letting gives .
Example. The analogous statement for squares is false: but , since has determinant .
Remark. More generally is operator monotone for (L\"owner-Heinz inequality) and not for . This result is one of the first examples where order on matrices behaves differently from order on numbers.