The complement of O(n) is path connected
Statement
Show that is path connected for . What happens for ?
Hint
Join every matrix to along a ray . The ray hits only when all singular values of are equal. If they are, perturb first.
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Idea. The origin is outside , and almost every ray from the origin avoids altogether. The few bad rays can be avoided by a small preliminary detour.
Step 0: when is a matrix orthogonal in terms of singular values? iff iff all singular values of equal .
Step 1: rays. For the singular values of are . So iff . Consequently:
- if the singular values of are *not all equal*, then for all (for we get );
- so joins to inside .
Step 2: the bad case. Suppose all singular values of are equal to . Then . If then . Otherwise , so with (since ).
- If : for , has all singular values equal to , so . The ray works again.
- If : consider , . Because and is orthogonal, the singular values of are : for they are not all equal, and for they are all . In both cases (at least one singular value is ... precisely, the *smallest* singular value is so none equals ). So is a path in the complement from to , whose singular values are *not all equal*. Then apply Step 1 to to go to .
Conclusion. Every point of the complement is joined to inside the complement, so it is path connected.
The case . and has three components. For Step 2 fails because again has all singular values equal.
Remark. The result expresses that has codimension in , which is enough to prevent it from separating space. The general principle: a closed submanifold of codimension never disconnects a connected manifold.