The sign of the determinant under squaring
Statement
Show that and are open in , and that maps into but is not onto when .
Hint
of an open half-line.
For non-surjectivity, find a matrix of determinant which is not a square (see Problem 74).
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Idea. is continuous, so preimages of open sets are open; multiplicativity of controls the sign of a square.
Step 1: openness. and are preimages of open sets by the continuous map .
Step 2: squares have positive determinant. For , , so .
Step 3: not onto for . The matrix has , so . If with real, the eigenvalues of are two conjugate non-real numbers or two real numbers; real would have , impossible, so they are , distinct. Then is diagonalisable over , so is , with eigenvalues : . Contradiction.
Remark.
- Combined with Problem 74: the image of squaring in is a *proper* subset of () it contains the open set of matrices with no negative eigenvalue (which have a real square root by the principal logarithm/power series), but it is not open-and-closed in in an obvious way.
- Squaring on is far from injective: and have the same square, and for also squares to .