Maths WorkshopMaths problems with full solutions
Exercise 683Topology › Topology of Mn(ℝ) › Continuity of matrix mapsL2Added 7 Nov 2026

The nilpotent cone is closed but not compact

#nilpotent matrices#fibre#Cayley-Hamilton#unbounded set

Statement

With χ\chi as in the previous problem, show that the fibre χ−1(0)={A:det⁡(tI−A)=tn}\chi^{-1}(0)=\{A:\det(tI-A)=t^n\} is exactly the set N\mathcal N of nilpotent matrices ("nilpotent cone"), that it is closed, and that it is unbounded for n≥2n\ge2.

Hint

Use the Cayley-Hamilton theorem in one direction and the eigenvalues in the other.

For unboundedness look at n=2n=2 and a single nonzero entry above the diagonal.

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

Idea. Characteristic polynomial tnt^n means that all complex eigenvalues are 00, which is the same as nilpotency.

Step 1: χA=tn⇒A\chi_A=t^n\Rightarrow A nilpotent. By the Cayley-Hamilton theorem, χA(A)=0\chi_A(A)=0, i.e. An=0A^n=0.

Step 2: AA nilpotent ⇒χA=tn\Rightarrow\chi_A=t^n. If Am=0A^m=0 and Av=λvAv=\lambda v with v≠0v\ne0 (λ∈C\lambda\in\mathbb{C}), then 0=Amv=λmv0=A^mv=\lambda^mv gives λ=0\lambda=0. So all complex roots of χA\chi_A vanish and, χA\chi_A being monic of degree nn, χA=tn\chi_A=t^n.

Step 3: closed. N=χ−1({0})\mathcal N=\chi^{-1}(\{0\}) is the preimage of a point under a continuous map (Problem 76), hence closed. Equivalently N={A:An=0}\mathcal N=\{A:A^n=0\} is the zero set of polynomial maps.

Step 4: unbounded. For s∈Rs\in\mathbb{R} let
Ns=(0s00)⊕0n−2.N_s=\begin{pmatrix}0&s\\0&0\end{pmatrix}\oplus 0_{n-2}.
Then Ns2=0N_s^2=0, so Ns∈NN_s\in\mathcal N, and ∥Ns∥=∣s∣\|N_s\|=|s| (it maps e2↦se1e_2\mapsto se_1 and kills the other basis vectors). Letting s→∞s\to\infty shows N\mathcal N is unbounded; hence it is not compact, although it is closed.

Remark. The nilpotent cone is a *cone*: tN∈NtN\in\mathcal N for all t∈Rt\in\mathbb{R} if N∈NN\in\mathcal N. It has empty interior (Part 2) and is singular at 00. For n=1n=1 the fibre is {0}\{0\} (a point), which explains the hypothesis n≥2n\ge2.