Maths WorkshopMaths problems with full solutions
Exercise 143Linear algebra › Linear mapsL1Added 3 Nov 2026

Image of a composition

#composition#image#inclusion

Statement

Let f:E→Ff:E\to F and g:F→Gg:F\to G be linear maps.

  1. Show that Im⁡(g∘f)⊆Im⁡g\operatorname{Im}(g\circ f)\subseteq\operatorname{Im} g.
  2. Show that equality holds if and only if Im⁡f+ker⁡g=F\operatorname{Im} f+\ker g=F. Deduce that equality holds when ff is surjective.
  3. Show by an example that surjectivity (or injectivity) of gg is not enough for equality.
Hint

The image of g∘fg\circ f is g(Im⁡f)g(\operatorname{Im} f). For (2), if g(y)=g(y′)g(y)=g(y') then y−y′∈ker⁡gy-y'\in\ker g.

Show solutionHide solution

Solution

(1) Im⁡(g∘f)=g(Im⁡f)⊆g(F)=Im⁡g\operatorname{Im}(g\circ f)=g(\operatorname{Im} f)\subseteq g(F)=\operatorname{Im} g.

(2) Equality ⇐\Leftarrow. Assume Im⁡f+ker⁡g=F\operatorname{Im} f+\ker g=F and let w∈Im⁡gw\in\operatorname{Im} g, say w=g(y)w=g(y). Write y=yf+ky=y_f+k with yf∈Im⁡fy_f\in\operatorname{Im} f and k∈ker⁡gk\in\ker g. Then w=g(yf)+g(k)=g(yf)∈g(Im⁡f)w=g(y_f)+g(k)=g(y_f)\in g(\operatorname{Im} f).

Equality ⇒\Rightarrow. Assume g(Im⁡f)=g(F)g(\operatorname{Im} f)=g(F) and let y∈Fy\in F. Then g(y)=g(yf)g(y)=g(y_f) for some yf∈Im⁡fy_f\in\operatorname{Im} f, so k:=y−yf∈ker⁡gk:=y-y_f\in\ker g and y=yf+k∈Im⁡f+ker⁡gy=y_f+k\in\operatorname{Im} f+\ker g.

Surjective ff. If Im⁡f=F\operatorname{Im} f=F, then Im⁡f+ker⁡g=F\operatorname{Im} f+\ker g=F, so Im⁡(g∘f)=Im⁡g\operatorname{Im}(g\circ f)=\operatorname{Im} g.

(3) Counterexample. Take f:R→Rf:\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R}, f=0f=0, and g=idRg=\mathrm{id}_{\mathbb{R}} (which is both injective and surjective). Then Im⁡(g∘f)={0}≠R=Im⁡g\operatorname{Im}(g\circ f)=\{0\}\neq\mathbb{R}=\operatorname{Im} g. Here Im⁡f+ker⁡g={0}≠R\operatorname{Im} f+\ker g=\{0\}\neq\mathbb{R}, as predicted by (2).

Conclusion. In general Im⁡(g∘f)⊆Im⁡g\operatorname{Im}(g\circ f)\subseteq\operatorname{Im} g, with equality exactly when Im⁡f+ker⁡g=F\operatorname{Im} f+\ker g=F (in particular when ff is surjective), and not merely when gg is surjective or injective.