Commuting maps on $[0,1]$ share a fixed point
Statement
Let be continuous and commute under composition:
1. Assume for every . Show there is such that, for every and every ,
where denotes the -fold iterate of .
- Deduce that there exists with .
Hint
- Apply the extreme value theorem to to get ; then argue by induction, using that and also commute (a consequence of ).
- Argue by contradiction: if never vanishes, it keeps a constant strict sign by the IVT, contradicting 1. since both iterates stay in .
Show solutionHide solution
Solution
Preliminary: iterates commute. From one checks by induction that and, more generally, that for all . We will use this in the inductive step.
Part 1. Let . Since is continuous on the compact interval , the extreme value theorem gives
Because for every , we have , and
*Base case .* This is exactly .
*Inductive step.* Suppose for all . Fix . Since , we may apply the inductive hypothesis to the point :
The left-hand side is . By the preliminary commutation, . Applying at the point gives
Combining,
This completes the induction.
Part 2. Suppose, for contradiction, that for every . Since is continuous on the interval , the intermediate value theorem forces to have a constant strict sign on .
*Case 1: on .* Part 1 then gives for every and . In particular,
Fix any . Since takes its values in , we have for all . Hence for all , which is impossible because and .
*Case 2: on .* Exchanging the roles of and in Part 1 produces the same contradiction.
Both cases are impossible, so the assumption everywhere fails. By continuity, there is with , i.e. .